A Forum for Vigorous Debate, Cornerstone of Democracy

***********************************************************************************************************************************
A FORUM FOR FREEDOM OF SPEECH AND VIGOROUS DEBATE, CORNERSTONES OF DEMOCRACY
[For the journal--guidelines, focus, etc.--go to www.theamericandissident.org. If you have questions, please contact me at todslone@hotmail.com. Comments are NOT moderated (i.e., CENSORED)!]
Encouraged censorship and self-censorship seem to have become popular in America today. Those who censor others, not just self, tend to favor the term "moderate," as opposed to "censor" and "moderation" to "censorship." But that doesn't change what they do. They still act as Little Caesars or Big Brother protectors of the thin-skinned. Democracy, however, demands a tough populace, not so easily offended. On this blog, and to buck the trend of censorship, banning, and ostracizing, comments are NEVER "moderated." Rarely (almost NEVER) do the targets of these blog entries respond in an effort to defend themselves with cogent counter-argumentation. This blog is testimony to how little academics, poets, critics, newspaper editors, cartoonists, political hacks, cultural council apparatchiks, librarians et al appreciate VIGOROUS DEBATE, cornerstone of democracy. Clearly, far too many of them could likely prosper just fine in places like communist China and Cuba or Saudi Arabia, Qatar, and Russia, not to mention Sweden, England, and Austria.
ISSUE #47 PUBLISHED MAY 2024. NOW SEEKING SUBMISSIONS FOR ISSUE #48.

More P. Maudit cartoons (and essays) at Global Free Press: http://www.globalfreepress.org

Monday, November 16, 2026

Professor Andrew Hartman

 


Below is a cartoon I created in 2018 regarding Andrew Hartman et al, as well as the correspondence with its regard.  As for the numerous comments on Hartman's Facebook page, regarding the cartoon, examine https://www.facebook.com/andrewghartman/posts/one-of-my-haters-made-a-political-cartoon-about-me-in-his-email-to-me-and-the-st/10156253237179910/.  Most of those comments, unsurprisingly, fail to address any of the points made in the cartoon.  In fact, most of the commenters don't seem to understand any of the points made.  Ad hominem and backslapping add spice to the comment vacuity.  Jeremy Miller's comment serves as an example:  "You have numerous accomplishments as an author and professor but dude...you’ve officially made it!!!! Some asshole sat and looked at a picture of you long enough to sketch together a “decent” picture of you! I’m so happy for you. I would hang that next to your Fullbright pennant!"  Elayne Tobin's comment (ad hominem, of course!) also serves as an example:   "He did a cartoon of me too Andrew Hartman! And wrote this jewel of a piece! What a freak... http://wwwtheamericandissidentorg.blogspot.com/2017/04/elayne-tobin.html?m=1."  The cartoon RE Tobin is actually here: https://www.blogger.com/blog/post/edit/239569862679528067/893424752272601902.  It seems that most of the commenters lack staunch individualism and ability to think outside of their safe-space (often academic) boxes.  Alas, socialism/communism is slowly but surely taking over and eliminating  freedom of expression, individuality, and the courage to stand not with a mob but alone and risk career... for the sake of rude truth.
................................................

.............................................................

From: George Slone <todslone@hotmail.com>

Sent: Friday, March 23, 2018 7:05 PM

To: ahartma@ilstu.edu

Cc: vidette@ilstu.edu

Subject: Your free speech WaPo article

 

To Andrew Hartman, History Professor, Illinois State University:  Well, I read through your WaPo Perspective Essay because of its odd title: “People always think students are hostile to speech. They never really are.”   Odd because the evidence is egregiously against it.  Most people (students et al) likely do not even know what speech is legally permitted and what isn’t.  Your article should have begun with a statement on that.  Also, have you ever personally tested the waters of democracy at Illinois State, for example?  Likely you have not.  Tenure and all the other academic perks depend on the see-no-evil, speak-no-evil anti-free-speech mindset.  Certainly, you must know that.  Personal experience with free-speech issues ought to precede writing about such issues.  FIRE, for some reason, does not want to address the real elephant in the free-speech room, which I sketched in a cartoon (see attached).  As for me, I’ve tested those waters for the past several decades in academe and elsewhere in the academic/literary establishment.  Those waters are terribly murky.  Most academics detest free speech and would certainly not stand up to defend it; so how is it that somehow they’re producing students who like it?  As written up on my website, I have even tested the waters of democracy at purported free-speech advocacy groups and venues from PEN New England, ACLUM, WaPo, Quillette, NCAC, Inside Higher Ed, etc.  There too the waters are terribly murky.  I suspect the same could be said about the Illinois State student newspaper, The Vidette.  Most student newspaper editors will not even respond to criticism pertinent to their institutions.  I know.  I’ve sent many a critique to them.  Again, if you do not step out of your safe-space sinecure, how will you ever really know what those waters are like?  Statistics?  Give me a break!  Perhaps you are not really interested in finding out.  BUT if you are, Illinois State is the place where you should begin.  Try here, for example:  https://www.thefire.org/schools/illinois-state-university.  Just press the TAKE ACTION red button…  

Sincerely,



G. Tod Slone, PhD (Université de Nantes, FR), aka P. Maudit,

Founding Editor (1998)

The American Dissident, a 501c3 Nonprofit Journal of Literature, Democracy, and Dissidence

www.theamericandissident.org

wwwtheamericandissidentorg.blogspot.com


The American Dissident

wwwtheamericandissidentorg.blogspot.com

Unsurprisingly, Christian Smith did not respond to the above cartoon. Unsurprisingly, Smith’s colleagues did not respond to it. Unsurprisingly, the student editors ...



todslone@hotmail.com

217 Commerce Rd.


Barnstable, MA 02630



From: George Slone <todslone@hotmail.com>

Sent: Saturday, March 24, 2018 9:33 AM

To: rajone1@ilstu.edu

Cc: ahartma@ilstu.edu; vidette_esasic@ilstu.edu

Subject: Backslapping and self-congratulating is not a reliable measure of freedom of speech

 

To Rick Jones, Faculty Emeritus in the School of Communication at Illinois State University and former general manager of The Vidette:  


Prizes, prizes, prizes!  Backslapping and self-congratulating!  What else is new in the world of journalism and academe?  It is not the prize that one should focus on, but rather the degree of openness to freedom of speech and real vigorous debate, which ought to be cornerstones of not only a thriving democracy but also of journalism, as opposed to PC-bias and identity politics-as-usual.  Journalism has become indelibly corrupt, in case you haven’t even noticed, yet all you can do is rah, rah, rah about the prizes it distributes and the journalists who receive them.  Would student Editor-in-Chief Ema Sasic even publish this email in The Vidette?  If she’s learned from her Mass Comm profs, you included, she will not! My two-decades-long experience testing the waters of student journalists underscores that very few of them will dare publish criticism--harsh criticism--of their professors and institutions.  SILENCE tends to be their response.  SILENCE tends to be their professors’ response.  Yes, the General Excellence Prize and 29 awards from the Illinois College Press Association contest accorded to The Vidette staff… and yet have any student journalists at The Vidette ever even contemplated pressing the little TAKE ACTION red button on the Foundation for Individual Rights in Education website, which underscores the free-speech muzzling policies in existence at Illinois State University (https://www.thefire.org/schools/illinois-state-university)?  SILENCE…



Illinois State University - FIRE

www.thefire.org

University Housing Services allows Registered Student Organizations and university departments to post fliers and posters in designated public areas with the ...




Sincerely,

G. Tod Slone, PhD (Université de Nantes, FR), aka P. Maudit,

Founding Editor (1998)

The American Dissident, a 501c3 Nonprofit Journal of Literature, Democracy, and Dissidence

www.theamericandissident.org

wwwtheamericandissidentorg.blogspot.com

todslone@hotmail.com

217 Commerce Rd.

Barnstable, MA 02630



From: George Slone <todslone@hotmail.com>

Sent: Monday, March 26, 2018 9:06 AM

To: vidette_esasic@ilstu.edu; vidette@ilstu.edu

Cc: ahartma@ilstu.edu; rajone1@ilstu.edu

Subject: Ema Sasic and Hartman satirized in a new P. Maudit cartoon

 

To Editor-in-Chief Ema Sasic, The Vidette, Student Newspaper of Illinois State University:

Please publish this email and the attached cartoon in The Vidette to help encourage ISU students to engage in free-speech issues.  You and Professors Andrew Hartman and Rick Jones are depicted in it.  Do you have the intellectual fortitude to publish it?  If not, then the prime difference between you and me is that if you had sent a cartoon satirizing me, I would definitely publish it in The American Dissident.  In fact, in each and every issue of the journal, I encourage harsh criticism with its and my regard… and always publish the harshest… and never punish the critic, as in you will no longer be published in The American Dissident.  Think about that, if at all possible.  The fate of journalism depends on it.  Pravda or not to Pravda?  Independent journalism or politically-correct journalism?  Those are the questions confronting journalism today in America.  Are you even aware of that?  


Sincerely,


G. Tod Slone, PhD (Université de Nantes, FR), aka P. Maudit,

Founding Editor (1998)

The American Dissident, a 501c3 Nonprofit Journal of Literature, Democracy, and Dissidence

www.theamericandissident.org

wwwtheamericandissidentorg.blogspot.com

todslone@hotmail.com

217 Commerce Rd.


Barnstable, MA 02630


From: Hartman, Andrew <ahartma@ilstu.edu>

Sent: Monday, March 26, 2018 9:15 AM

To: George Slone

Cc: Sasic, Ema; dv_Editor; Jones, Richard

Subject: Re: Ema Sasic and Hartman satirized in a new P. Maudit cartoon

 

Dear G. Tod Slone,


I wouldn’t mind the fine student editors at The Vedette publishing this political cartoon— I just tweeted it to my 4,500 + followers. Nice job on the links, by the way! But aren’t political cartoons supposed to be funny or clear if not both? 


Warmest regards,


Andrew



Andrew Hartman

Professor of History

Illinois State University


From: Hartman, Andrew <ahartma@ilstu.edu>

Sent: Monday, March 26, 2018 9:19 AM

To: George Slone

Cc: Sasic, Ema; dv_Editor; Jones, Richard

Subject: Re: Ema Sasic and Hartman satirized in a new P. Maudit cartoon

 

That should read “likeness,” not links.


Andrew Hartman

Professor of History

Illinois State University



From: George Slone <todslone@hotmail.com>

Sent: Monday, March 26, 2018 9:46 AM

To: Hartman, Andrew

Subject: Re: Ema Sasic and Hartman satirized in a new P. Maudit cartoon

 

Hi Andrew,

Thanks for the response.  But I'd be quite surprised if your "fine editors" at ISU would publish the cartoon for the reasons stipulated in my email.  I have been sending cartoons like that one to student editors around the country for several decades now.  Only once (Syracuse University) did student editors publish the cartoon.  And only a handful of times did they deign to even respond.  When I was a prof at Fitchburg State University (MA) for 5 years on the tenure track, the student editors would NOT publish anything I sent critical of the college.  

Finally, a broad statement about lacking clarity is nothing but thinly-disguised ad hominem.  Be precise.  What precisely was not clear?  Without precision, one cannot respond to the criticism.  Also, targets of "political cartoons" will normally not find the cartoons in the least bit funny.  

The cartoon will appear in the forthcoming issue (to be sent to the printer's next week) of The American Dissident with your response.  Perhaps your library might wish to subscribe (only $20/year) and be the only library in Illinois to do so?  Then ISU students might actually be able to examine the cartoon... and engage in vigorous debate.  Harvard, Yale, Buffalo, Johns Hopkins, Brown, and a few other university libraries have been subscribing.  Librarians, however, in general, tend to be flaming hypocrites, especially with regards to their collection development policies, in particular, "libraries should provide materials and information presenting all points of view" (ALA).  In fact, I even got permanently trespassed w/o warning and w/o due process from my neighborhood library in 2012 because I brought that hypocrisy to the attention of the hypocrite library director.  Now, do you think James LaRue, director of the ALA's Office for Intellectual Freedom gave a damn?  Of course not!  You might wish to examine my lengthy exchange with him:  

http://wwwtheamericandissidentorg.blogspot.com/2017/04/james-larue.html.  


Anyhow,, I suppose, I digress... or sort of.  Thanks again for responding.  I suppose I'll never know for certain if you responded because I sent an email directly to the student editor.  :)


G. Tod



From: George Slone <todslone@hotmail.com>

Sent: Tuesday, March 27, 2018 9:29 AM

To: Hartman, Andrew

Subject: Re: Ema Sasic and Hartman satirized in a new P. Maudit cartoon

 

And how about the Stalin comparison?  But once again you miss the point!  Quantity uber quality.  Popularity uber rude-truth individuality.  And of course the big point you miss is actual, real, personal, risky testing the waters of free speech.  Few academics can grasp that point for evident reasons.  To do so, means to question and challenge ones very own careerist modus operandi.  Anyhow, we actually engaged in a little debate, though quite brief...

T



From: Hartman, Andrew <ahartma@ilstu.edu>

Sent: Tuesday, March 27, 2018 8:11 AM

To: George Slone

Subject: Re: Ema Sasic and Hartman satirized in a new P. Maudit cartoon

 

I wasn’t bragging, merely saying I’m not afraid of people seeing your political cartoon about me. But of course the Hitler comparison. I guess you couldn’t help yourself.


Andrew Hartman

Professor of History

Illinois State University



From: George Slone <todslone@hotmail.com>

Sent: Tuesday, March 27, 2018 7:42 AM

To: Hartman, Andrew

Subject: Re: Ema Sasic and Hartman satirized in a new P. Maudit cartoon

 

An Afterthought

So, you say you have 4,500 “followers.”  Well, how many did Hitler have?  Or Mao or Stalin?  Quantity uber quality seems to reign in academe and literature today.  You might wish to discuss that with your students!  

Kudos to Ema Sasic for being open to diversity of opinion!  She is RARE in student journalism—certainly NOT common!  Period.  I thus sent her an apologia and even corrected the cartoon.

BUT… and this is a big BUT… nobody has yet addressed the points made regarding ISU’s Yellow light rating and actual risk-taking testing of the waters of free speech at ISU, not to mention likely student ignorance of the First Amendment.  In essence, what precisely is free speech in America.  Silence.  I thus rest my case…


T


From: George Slone <todslone@hotmail.com>

Sent: Monday, March 26, 2018 5:43 PM

To: Sasic, Ema

Subject: Corrected Cartoon attached

 

See attached for correct cartoon and apologia.

G. Tod



From: Sasic, Ema <vidette_esasic@ilstu.edu>

Sent: Monday, March 26, 2018 1:54 PM

To: George Slone

Subject: Re: Ema Sasic and Hartman satirized in a new P. Maudit cartoon

 

Mr. Slone, 


I am a journalist who believes in fairness and being as unbias as possible. If a piece criticizes me, so be it. The Vidette is a place for everyone to express their opinions. 


Here is a link to today's paper, with your first letter on page 4: https://issuu.com/videtteonline/docs/3.26.18web


Best, 

Ema


Ema Sasic

Editor-in-Chief | The Vidette


From: George Slone <todslone@hotmail.com>

Sent: Monday, March 26, 2018 12:31:38 PM

To: Sasic, Ema

Subject: Re: Ema Sasic and Hartman satirized in a new P. Maudit cartoon

 

Hi Ema,

Thanks for being willing to publish the items, especially the one with your depiction.  That takes true guts and passion for freedom of expression.  Kudos!  Could you send me the print version or will it not be in the print version?  And of course nothing at all personal.  After all, I do not know you.

Best,

G. Tod



From: Sasic, Ema <vidette_esasic@ilstu.edu>

Sent: Monday, March 26, 2018 10:59 AM

To: George Slone

Subject: Re: Ema Sasic and Hartman satirized in a new P. Maudit cartoon

 

Mr. Slone,


Thank you for today’s submission and all previous ones. 


The first was published in today’s paper, and it will be online later today as well. The other submissions will be uploaded online throughout the week. 


Best,

Ema


Get Outlook for iOS

From: George Slone <todslone@hotmail.com>

Sent: Monday, March 26, 2018 8:06:19 AM

To: Sasic, Ema; dv_Editor

Cc: Hartman, Andrew; Jones, Richard

Subject: Ema Sasic and Hartman satirized in a new P. Maudit cartoon

 

To Editor-in-Chief Ema Sasic, The Vidette, Student Newspaper of Illinois State University:

Please publish this email and the attached cartoon in The Vidette to help encourage ISU students to engage in free-speech issues.  You and Professors Andrew Hartman and Rick Jones are depicted in it.  Do you have the intellectual fortitude to publish it?  If not, then the prime difference between you and me is that if you had sent a cartoon satirizing me, I would definitely publish it in The American Dissident.  In fact, in each and every issue of the journal, I encourage harsh criticism with its and my regard… and always publish the harshest… and never punish the critic, as in you will no longer be published in The American Dissident.  Think about that, if at all possible.  The fate of journalism depends on it.  Pravda or not to Pravda?  Independent journalism or politically-correct journalism?  Those are the questions confronting journalism today in America.  Are you even aware of that?  


Sincerely,


G. Tod Slone, PhD (Université de Nantes, FR), aka P. Maudit,

Founding Editor (1998)

The American Dissident, a 501c3 Nonprofit Journal of Literature, Democracy, and Dissidence

www.theamericandissident.org

wwwtheamericandissidentorg.blogspot.com

todslone@hotmail.com

217 Commerce Rd.


Barnstable, MA 02630



From: George Slone <todslone@hotmail.com>

Sent: Monday, January 29, 2018 9:05 AM

To: elayne.tobin@nyu.edu

Cc: Rosalyn Becker

Subject: Hillary said the B-word... Oh, my!

 

To Professor Elayne Tobin, aka Dr. Sticks and Stones May Break My Bones, But Names Will Hurt Me Even More:  


Thought of you the other day because, well, your ex-hippie feminist idol, Hillary Clinton, recently said the B-word in public:  “Thanks for your feminism, for your activism, and all I can hope is you keep up the really important, good work.  And let me just say, this is directed to the activist bitches supporting bitches. So let’s go.”



So, am I now also permitted to use the B-word?  Or are only elite multimillionaire socialist females parading around as feminists permitted to do that?  


Anyhow, no hatred here at all.  Just raising the specter at NYU of Vigorous Debate, cornerstone of democracy.


Sincerely,


G. Tod Slone, PhD (Universite de Nantes, FR) aka P. Maudit,

Founding Editor (1998)

The American Dissident, a 501c3 Nonprofit Journal of Literature, Democracy, and Dissidence

www.theamericandissident.org

wwwtheamericandissidentorg.blogspot.com

todslone@hotmail.com


.................................
NO RESPONSE FROM TOBIN!!!    Silence is golden in the realm of the ivory tower, certainly NOT freedom of speech and vigorous debate, cornerstones of a thriving democracy...